Tacrolimus (FK506) versus cyclosporin a microemulsion (neoral) maintenance immunosuppression: effects on graft survival and function, infection, and metabolic profile following kidney transplantation (KT)

Abstract

We reviewed two groups of kidney transplant patients receiving neoral (Group I, 27 patients) or FK506 (Group II, 25 patients) as maintenance immunosuppression between December 1998 and May 2002. The recipient and donor demographics and induction therapy were comparable in both groups except for more highly sensitized patients in Group II. Acute rejection (AR) rate and timing were similar in both groups except for more steroid resistant AR in Group II (P=0.04). Infections rate was similar in both groups (25.9% in Group I and 36% in Group II; P=N.S.), but there were less viral infections in Group I (0%) than Group II (29%; 4 CMV). CMV infections were related to the presence in Group II of more CMV-negative recipients getting kidneys from CMV-positive donors. The metabolic profile was comparable between the two groups, except for a better HDL in Group II (48.2±7.6) versus Group I (45±2.2; P=0.021). Mean serum creatinine levels upon discharge, at 1, 3 and 6 months were: 1.62±0.32, 1.4±0.17, 1.39±0.14 and 1.4±0.14 in Group I and 2.15±0.5, 1.48±0.23, 1.41±0.21 and 1.23±0.11 in Group II, respectively. The 6 months actuarial patient and graft survival were identical in both groups (100 and 100%). Both calcineurin inhibitors are effective and safe in KT. The higher rate of AR in Group II was related to more highly sensitized patients and the higher CMV infections was due to the presence of more CMV-negative recipients receiving kidneys from CMV-positive donors. The same study will be continued to evaluate the long term effects of both drugs.